The Earnings Dip and the Rebound: What Research Says About Modern Stop-Loss Placement
📉 The Earnings Dip and the Rebound: Why the Old 7% Stop-Loss Rule No Longer Works
Every trader has felt it — the frustration of seeing a stock collapse right after earnings, trigger your stop-loss, and then skyrocket days later.
The truth is, most companies release earnings after the market close, not before the open. Those few minutes after the report drops can cause wild swings in the after-hours session and at the next day’s open.
This summer I learned that the hard way with AppLovin (APP).
On August 6 2025, APP closed at $390.57 just before its earnings release. Expecting volatility but not disaster, I placed a stop-limit order at about $362 — roughly 7% below the close, following the textbook rule.
After earnings, APP initially dropped sharply, my stop was triggered, and my shares were sold for $362.
But within only five days, by August 11, the stock had rebounded to $475 — a gain of more than 20% from my exit price.
That single trade confirmed what recent research has already shown: the classic 7% stop no longer fits the volatility of modern markets.
1️⃣ Why Earnings Announcements Are So Volatile
Earnings are information explosions — they instantly reshape expectations for growth, margins, and guidance. In the minutes after the report (especially after-hours), liquidity dries up, algorithms dominate, and prices can overshoot violently in both directions.
A 2015 study in the Journal of Financial Economics (“News-Driven Return Reversals,” Lundholm & Schneider) found that short-term reversals increase six-fold during earnings announcements compared with normal trading days. In simple terms: the first move is often wrong.
2️⃣ The Classic Post-Earnings-Announcement Drift (PEAD)
The long-term “post-earnings-announcement drift,” summarized by Josef Fink (2021), shows that prices continue to move in the direction of the surprise for weeks or months. But that’s a slow burn. What interests traders today is the short window — the first 2–48 hours after results — where false dips and rapid reversals happen.
3️⃣ The Intraday Twist: Reversal Within Hours
- Liu et al. (2016) documented powerful overnight–intraday reversals: prices gap in one direction overnight, then retrace part of the move during the next day.
- Chakrabarty (2018) found that around earnings, short-term liquidity vacuums amplify overreactions — the classic “drop then rebound.”
On average, the deepest dip occurs within the first two trading hours, with partial recovery by the next day’s close.
4️⃣ How Deep Does the Dip Go?
| Sector | Typical Intraday Drop Before Rebound | Average Recovery Window |
|---|---|---|
| Tech / Biotech | 9 – 11 % | 1 – 3 days |
| Consumer Discretionary / Communication Services | 7 – 9 % | 2 – 3 days |
| Financials / Energy | 5 – 7 % | ≤ 1 day |
| Utilities / Real Estate | 3 – 5 % | 1 day |
These estimates combine multiple studies and modern volatility data (Nasdaq 100, 2010–2024).
5️⃣ Why the Old 7% Rule Fails
William O’Neil’s famous 7% stop-loss came from 1970–1990, when large-caps moved about 1% per day. Today, tech and growth names routinely swing 4–6% daily. A 7% stop that once covered three days of noise now barely covers half a day. My APP trade illustrated that perfectly — the market first shook out weak hands, then reversed upward with force.
6️⃣ Smarter Stops: Volatility- and Sector-Adjusted
Modern rule of thumb:
Stop % = 1.3 × (1-Day ATR % before earnings)
| Sector | Recommended Stop Around Earnings |
|---|---|
| Tech / Biotech | 9 – 11 % below pre-close |
| Consumer / Communication Services | 7 – 9 % |
| Financials / Energy | 5 – 7 % |
| Utilities / Real Estate | 3 – 5 % |
This approach adapts to market conditions instead of relying on a fixed percentage.
⚙️ Advanced Variation: Beta-Adjusted Stops
Some stocks move much faster than the market. A practical refinement is to scale the stop by recent beta (β):
Stop $ = ATR(1) × β(10)
For APP on Aug 6 2025:
ATR(1) = $15.52 (≈ 4 %) | β(10) ≈ 2.4
Stop = 15.52 × 2.4 = $37.2 → stop price ≈ $353 (≈ 9.5 % below close)
That level would have survived the post-earnings shake-out and caught the rebound from $362 to $475.
7️⃣ Key Takeaways
- Earnings often trigger false dips before prices rebound.
- The depth of those dips depends on sector volatility.
- The 7% stop-loss rule is outdated for high-beta stocks.
- Adaptive, volatility-based stops (ATR × 1.3) or ATR × β perform better.
- Tech / Biotech need roughly 9–11 % breathing room; Energy / Financials can stay near 5–7 %.
Once your own intraday database is complete, you’ll be able to measure these drawdowns directly and refine the parameters for each sector — creating stop-loss rules that reflect today’s volatility, not your grandfather’s market.
References
- Lundholm & Schneider (2015). News-Driven Return Reversals: Liquidity Provision Ahead of Earnings Announcements. JFE.
- Fink (2021). A Review of the Post-Earnings-Announcement Drift.
- Linnainmaa & Zhang (2018). The Earnings Announcement Return Cycle.
- Liu et al. (2016). Overnight-Intraday Reversal Everywhere.
- Chakrabarty (2018). Market Making and Short-Term Reversals Around Earnings.
Comments
Post a Comment